Introduction
Misuse of topical steroids is not the new entity in this era but has increased exponentially, as the availability of over the counter medication in surplus combinations with both relevant and irrelevant. As we blame the society for the misuse secondary to lack of knowledge but misuse of topical steroids is rampant even in the healthcare fraternity. More alarmingly misuse in the medical students is increasing due to lack of application of knowledge or meagre knowledge on the usage of topical steroids. In many of the studies, general practitioners (GP) form a sizable population in prescribing the topical steroids for common skin ailments. GPs either use approved steroid combination like Kligman’s formula for pigment reduction or irrelevant steroid combination for fungal infection. Thorough knowledge about the steroid molecule regarding where not to use more than where to use is more important which should be ideally start from their first clinical dermatology exposure. This study analyses the awareness of the medical students towards topical steroids and imposes the knowledge regarding the same.
Table 1
Table 2
Indication |
No of patient |
Percentage |
Not used |
18 |
13.5 |
Fungal infection |
21 |
15.8 |
Fairness cream |
35 |
26.3 |
Eczema |
14 |
10.5 |
Rashes |
8 |
6 |
Acne |
14 |
10.5 |
Hyperpigmentation |
23 |
17.3 |
Table 3
Table 4
Table 5
S.No |
Place of study |
Study details (Author/ Year) |
Participants |
Steroid formulation known |
Prescribed by |
Indication for use |
Major ADR |
Awareness given Yes/no |
1 |
Chengalpattu, Tamilnadu |
Our study |
6th semester medical students |
Combination steroids (relevant and irrelevant FDC) |
Pharmacist ,friends and relatives (55.2) |
Fairness cream, fungal infection |
Hypo/hyper pigmentation, erythema, epidermal atrophy |
Yes |
2 |
Jeddah, Saudi Arabia 1 |
Dhiyaa Majed, Mahdi Alnujaidi, 2018 |
University students |
Combination steroid and mild steroid |
Friends and relatives, pharmacist |
Acne, facial pigmentation, after shave erythema |
Hypo/hyper pigmentation, dryness, sensitive skin, recurrence of condition |
No |
3 |
Perinthalmanna, Kerala, India 2 |
Karalikkattil T. Ashique, Feroze Kaliyadan, 2018 |
Pharmacy students- UG&PG |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
4 |
Bengaluru, Karnataka, India 3 |
T S Nagesh, A Akhilesh,2016 |
Patients attending Dermatology OPD |
Betamethasone, kligmans formula |
General practitioners, friends, pharmacist |
Acne, allergy, pigmentation, fairness cream |
Aggravation of symptoms, hypo/hyper pigmentation, acne |
No |
5 |
Quaid-e-Azam Medical College, Bahawalpur, Pakistan 4 |
Sohail Shaheen, Asma Shahbaz, Nimra Maqbool, Jamil Ahmad Shaheen,2020 |
Female medical students |
Betamethasone, clobetasol, mixed creams (irrelevant FDC) |
Pharmacist, friends, some by beauty parlour |
Acne, Fairness cream |
- |
No |
6 |
King George's Medical University, Lucknow, India 5 |
Parul Verma , Sucheta Pathania , Swastika Suvirya , Prakriti Shukla |
Medical students (Interns, postgraduates) |
Clobetasol , Betamethasone, Beclomethasone. |
- |
Eczema, acne, infections |
- |
Yes |
7 |
Saveetha university, Chennai, India 6 |
Aarthi Muthukumar, Dhanraj Ganapathy |
Dental students |
All classes |
- |
- |
Aware of ADR |
|
8 |
Dow University of Health Sciences, Karachi, Pakistan 7 |
Fakhsheena Anjum, Auwais Ahmed Khan et al |
Pharmacy students and Allied health sciences |
Topical, oral and injectable |
Medical practitioner> self > trainer |
Skin brightening, antiinflammatory, anti infective |
Aware of ADR |
No |
9 |
Allama Iqbal Medical College, Lahore 8 |
Samina Naz Chohan, Majid Suhail, Samia Salman |
Patients attending dermatology OPD |
Potent topical steroids- clobetasol and beta-methasone |
Friends> relatives >peers> GP |
Acne, pigmentation, melasma |
Facial erythema, aggravation of existing symptoms, hypertrichosis |
No |
10 |
Mamata Dental College, Khammam, India 9 |
Kokkalgave Supriya1 , K. V. N. R. Pratap2 , |
Dental students both UG and PG |
Topical corticosteroid |
- |
Acne, hyper pigmentation |
Aware of ADR |
No |
11 |
Adichunchanagiri Institute of Medical Sciences, Karnataka, India 10 |
Mukunda Ranga Swaroop1,*, Suman Swamynathan |
Patients attending dermatology OPD |
Irrelevant combination with steroid |
Friends > GP> neighbours and relatives |
Acne, pigmentary disturbance |
Acneform eruptions, pigmentation and burning sensation |
|
12 |
Riyadh, Kingdom of Saudi Arabia 11 |
Sarah F. Alsukait, Najd A. Alshamlan et al |
Primary care physicians (GP, Family medicine, Internal medicine , pediatrics) |
Topical steroid |
- |
Atopic dermatitis, psoriasis, alopecia areata, acne vulgaris |
Atrophy, hypopigmentation, striae |
No |
Materials and Methods
6th semester medical students were enrolled in this study with prior Institutional Ethical clearance and with informed consent from the individuals. Out of 100 students excluding absentees and the ones not interested in participating were excluded from the study. Enrolled 76 students were given a validated pretest questionnaire and were asked to fill out the same. Questionnaire included the demographic details, questions related to the topic including about the topical steroid used, duration of use, knowledge of adverse effects, potency of steroid and indications and contraindications around 15 questions. After that students were exposed to the presentation regarding topical steroid use and misuse. After 3 months of this activity, students were evaluated with the same set of questions. The results were analyzed by t test, p values and with 95% confidence interval via SPSS software.
Results
6th semester students who participated in this study were between 20-21 years and with 45 females and 21 male students. 75% of the students already heard about the topical steroid preparation with only 2% had prescribed the medication to others (Table 1 ). 47% had seen the topical steroid medications being used by their close contacts. Irrelevant steroid combinations (steroid, antifungal, antibiotic) were the ones commonly used in 57.9% followed by Kligman’s formula (36.8%) and only 5.3% had used plain topical steroids (n=57). Steroid based topical preparations were used as a fairness cream (26.3%) and for hyperpigmentation (17.3%) and closely followed by fungal infections (15.8%) rather than other causes (Table 2). Out of this Dermi5, Quadriderm, Fourderm and Castor NF were the ones used for fungal infection and Skinlite, Melacare, Skinshine were used for facial melanosis. Only 44.8% were prescribed by dermatologist and general practitioner but the remaining 55.2% medications bought without the prescription mostly suggested by the Pharmacist or by friends or by relatives or by self. About 13% of the patients used the topical medication beyond the prescribed period. 52.6% had used the medication for maximum one month and 14.4% had used up to 1 year duration. In this 40.8% patients used the medications continuously compared to 27.6% who had used intermittently. Reasons for usage beyond the prescribed period of steroid were no relief from the existing symptoms, glow to the skin on usage and colour reducing effect (Table 3).
On comparing the pre and post test results, there is significant increase in the awareness regarding long term use of topical steroids (p<0.5, chisquare 5.2) and the knowledge of the adverse events (p<0.5, chisquare 8.1). Students have gained significant knowledge regarding the potency and using the prescribed topical steroids for prescribed period of time. Most of the student’s knowledge regarding the counselling related to topical drug usage, advising regarding the adverse events had been significantly improved (Table 4).
Discussion
Most of the available literature regarding topical steroid abuse had only demographic details and are cross sectional studies and are not follow up studies. Comparison of other studies with our study is tabulated below (Table 5).
Currently available TCs differ widely, and knowledge of such differences is vital for proper prescribing practices. When prescribing TCs, it is important to consider the indication, patient’s age, TCs potency, vehicle, frequency, duration, site of lesion, severity of disease, and associated adverse effects. 12
If medical students, who are a vital part of the health community and who should be strongly opposing the idea of misuse of drugs are using TCs for cosmetic purposes upon themselves, then it will be a matter of immense concern.4 All MBBS students will not be dermatologists and dermatologists cannot be everywhere, so the knowledge regarding topical steroids is mandatory and it should be included in the curriculum.5
In a study conducted in Saveetha University with dental students concluded that most of them are aware of topical steroid formulation and their usage and adverse events which is comparable to our study. 6 Another study from Riyadh concluded that the knowledge among primary care physicians regarding use of topical corticosteroids was lacking in more than half of the PCPs 11 as with our study.
Knowledge gaps towards TCs could be attributed to the lack of proper dermatology training in undergraduate curriculum. Another fact observed was the physicians who felt comfortable treating dermatology patients had significant knowledge regarding topical steroid usage. 11 This supports our study that knowledge facilitated during their training will induce the students to treat comfortably the dermatology patients when they become medical graduates. Another important factor is reinforcing the importance of proper use of topical steroids and treating dermatology patients will gradually abolish the misuse of topical steroids.
In a study aimed to assess the learning outcomes of a 10-week postgraduate training course in dermatology among PCPs, most PCPs reported modifying their approach in managing common skin disorders after the course. 13 As with the study stated not only after the graduation but during their undergraduate curriculum also and this has to regularly reinforced during the curriculum which will make the medical graduate competent to treat dermatology patients and avoid the misuse of the topical corticosteroids.
Conclusion
As with the saying “The eye is blind if the mind is absent”, knowledge regarding the topical steroids which is not imparted in the undergraduate curriculum will lead to ultimate misuse. So inclusion of the topical steroid in the undergraduate curriculum is mandatory and also the dermatology postings in the internship period should be made compulsory rather than optional.